I think we understand that it isn't going to happen. We're not debating whether it not it will but whether or not it should. And yes, it definitely should happen. Going off your logic, Hairston was brought into a starting role and once Weeks comes back, if he's benched, shouldn't he have some beef? Obviously the answer is no because Hairston is a professional. He understands that he was brought in to hold down the fort while Weeks recovered from injury. He understands that this team is trying to win and in doing so, Weeks should be starting once he's healthy. Similarly, Yuni/McGehee are also professionals. They should understand that a spot start once a week for other guys isn't a demotion. It's just meant to keep these other players fresh while also giving them some time to rest for the playoffs. I could maybe get behind your argument that handing the starting job to Green and Hairston/Wilson/Counsell (or even platooning) would throw off the clubhouse. However, and this has been beaten to death, one start a week SHOULDN'T be so big of a deal that they can't handle it and they freak out.