Even with Sheets' injury, Suppan might be the Brewer's 5th best starter. Gallardo will be rested up, so you have to go with him game 1, IMO. Pencil McClung to relieve him and give 2-3 innings. After that, the decisions get A LOT tougher. I don't like the thought of pitching CC on 3 days rest yet again, since the average starter just isn't as good doing it. Sabathia hasn't looked like the average starter while doing it, though, so I think I'd roll the dice and give him game 2. Bush game 3. Do you bring Gallardo back on 3 days rest for game 4? I think that would be irresponsible personally. I'd be fine with Johnny Wholestaff, myself. That leaves CC and even Gallardo available game 5, if needed. So: Game 1: Gallardo Game 2: Sabathia Game 3: Bush Game 4: Johnny Wholestaff Game 5: Sabathia/Gallardo If you can get it done in 4 games, you have Sabathia and Gallardo fully rested and ready to go for the next round.