I agree mostly with the original poster. A few random thoughts: * LaPorta is no where near ready, for anyone wanting to see him starting in the majors on opening day. That said, Melvin still may be eying him up for 2009, so a Gross/RH batter platoon wouldn't surprise me. * Capuano is either in the rotation or traded. Melvin wouldn't waste his value in the pen. * Because of his injury history, Melvin is probably going to be hesitant to thrust him right into the starting rotation. * I hate Estrada too but barring a trade, he is by far the best option. We can only hope that a healed up Estrada can bounce back a bit, offensively and defensively (throws to 2B, power). * I'd love to see Melvin do something drastic to try and help the team defense (Braun to a corner OF spot, Hall to 3B, Hart to CF), but I don't see it happening.