He traded a 25 year old who was crushing the ball in Nashville before he even got a chance with the team. He traded that player, along with our best trade asset at the time for a reliever with 1.5 years left on his contract, a weak side platoon outfielder and an outfielder who was a year younger than Cruz, had almost 800 major league at bats and a .286 OBP. If he trades Cruz, that's fine but when you trade him and our best trade asset for that group of players, people will have a problem with it. I get what you are saying here, but there have been other guys around that age that never get the shot in MLB or when they do it doesn't pan out. On the other hand, why didn't Milwaukee call up Cruz? It seems really odd that Melvin was off on Cruz given his history of either being smart or lucky with trading prospects. Does anyone recall if Texas held out for Cruz or if he was really just a throw in? I don't have a problem with trading Cruz, but the return wasn't very good for Lee and Cruz.