I'm not really sure what to think. He's heading into his second arbitration year, I really like the arms that we're giving up and Nolasco did come off a 5 ERA (I agree he was unlucky this year, but I don't know how much into sabermetrics the Marlins staff is, so I don't know if they thought he was terrible or unlucky). I'm just not sure about the deal, that probably means it's fair, I just don't know if giving up prospects is the right way to go right now.