Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic

Game 10 - Vikings @ Packers - Sunday, Nov. 15th @ 12:00 PM


Posted

I've never seen offensive line play this bad ever. Not from the Packers anyway. You'd have to go all the way back to the 70s to see that level of ineptitude. They look absolutely lost out there, repeatedly not knowing what to do. It's as if they didn't practice at all. That falls on Gutey as much as the coaching. He just can't evaluate an offensive lineman to save his life. That's grounds for termination alone, but we know that won't happen because we have an incompetent president running the show now, whom I blame the most for this. Policy should do the honorable thing and step down at season's end. It's not 70s/80s bad yet, but it can get that bad in a hurry with the current regime we have.

You think you can hurt me? I watch the Packers in January. You can't hurt me.

Posted
5 hours ago, adambr2 said:

Their offensive line sucks. That’s agreeable and clear and obvious and a tough barrier to overcome. The rest of this is just using words to paint/support a narrative. Love was considered an MVP candidate a week ago and now he’s supposedly someone who isn’t even good enough to elevate players around him. I think Watson and Golden would both disagree with that.

”A WR who drops too many passes” is also an extreme and negative oversimplification of Golden, who does drop too many passes but also does many things at a high level, particularly for a young WR with limited experience. 

MVP candidate, says who?  Maybe as the choice of Clickbait artists or Kalshi but he’s not a serious contender. 

The Packers are 6-4 with exactly one win against a winning team (and that was Chicago with Caleb Williams injured). And just to be clear I like the guy, but beating bad teams doesn’t win you an MVP award no matter how many passing yards you have. The Packers still have the Rams, Bills Lions & Bears.

If Love is genuinely an MVP-caliber quarterback, shouldn't we expect him to win at least two or three of those four difficult games, rather than simply accumulate impressive passing statistics?

What would you have me say that’s not a negative oversimplification of Golden? A talented young player who leaves too many players on the field? He’s got a 58% catch rate. I don’t know if it can be oversimplified

Posted

Saw a tweet earlier today with initial PFF pass block ratings.

Jordan Morgan was over 70 (must have been really good other than the time that Dallas Turner ran him over).

Anthony Belton was over 50.

Everyone else was under 20.

Laken Tomlinson was 0.

 

Posted
6 hours ago, adambr2 said:

MLF: “Bottom line, they’ve (Vikings pass rush) given everyone problems.”

 

I actually hate this guy. I really do.

 

That is true, they had averaged 3.625 sacks per game and their 29 sacks total was 2nd in the NFL.  Now LaFleur can explain why the Packer's offensive line gave up 8 sacks, more than twice their average.

  • Like 1
Posted
6 hours ago, Jopal78 said:

MVP candidate, says who?  Maybe as the choice of Clickbait artists or Kalshi but he’s not a serious contender. 

The Packers are 6-4 with exactly one win against a winning team (and that was Chicago with Caleb Williams injured). And just to be clear I like the guy, but beating bad teams doesn’t win you an MVP award no matter how many passing yards you have. The Packers still have the Rams, Bills Lions & Bears.

If Love is genuinely an MVP-caliber quarterback, shouldn't we expect him to win at least two or three of those four difficult games, rather than simply accumulate impressive passing statistics?

What would you have me say that’s not a negative oversimplification of Golden? A talented young player who leaves too many players on the field? He’s got a 58% catch rate. I don’t know if it can be oversimplified

Because the premise of your original point was that MLF is a flawed but adequate head coach who is simply hamstrung by the personnel that he has to work with, and “a WR who drops too many passes” would seem to imply that getting a weapon like Golden is a detriment to what MLF can do offensively. 

Yes, Golden drops too many passes. He’s also an elite separator. The drop issue is fixable, he is still a high end talent. Puka, Chase, ARSB have all been among the league’s drop leaders at various times the last few years, it isn’t a very telling stat as far as an inadequate WR.

Gute has had some failures over the years, and in particular, Banks and Hobbs have really hurt us the last couple seasons. But I would say in most areas other than the offensive line, he’s done an above average job accumulating talent on the roster and the coaching staff has not done a good enough job putting the players in the right position to succeed, particularly on offense. 

Look at the job Gannon has done on defense this year without Parsons and Cooper and contrast that to what MLF, Stenavich and Butkus have done with the offense. 

Gute also isn’t the one who continues to keep Luke Butkus as part of the coaching staff, despite clearly being one of the worst coached position units that the league has right now. 

You have TJ Lang and Mason Crosby calling out the Packer offensive coaching staff publicly today. It’s not just Monday reactions from the usual armchair GMs. 

Posted
7 hours ago, adambr2 said:

Because the premise of your original point was that MLF is a flawed but adequate head coach who is simply hamstrung by the personnel that he has to work with, and “a WR who drops too many passes” would seem to imply that getting a weapon like Golden is a detriment to what MLF can do offensively. 

Yes, Golden drops too many passes. He’s also an elite separator. The drop issue is fixable, he is still a high end talent. Puka, Chase, ARSB have all been among the league’s drop leaders at various times the last few years, it isn’t a very telling stat as far as an inadequate WR.

Gute has had some failures over the years, and in particular, Banks and Hobbs have really hurt us the last couple seasons. But I would say in most areas other than the offensive line, he’s done an above average job accumulating talent on the roster and the coaching staff has not done a good enough job putting the players in the right position to succeed, particularly on offense. 

Look at the job Gannon has done on defense this year without Parsons and Cooper and contrast that to what MLF, Stenavich and Butkus have done with the offense. 

Gute also isn’t the one who continues to keep Luke Butkus as part of the coaching staff, despite clearly being one of the worst coached position units that the league has right now. 

You have TJ Lang and Mason Crosby calling out the Packer offensive coaching staff publicly today. It’s not just Monday reactions from the usual armchair GMs. 

I’d slow your roll with heaping praise on Gannon. Their defense allows 22.1 points per game, which  puts them right in the middle of the pack, and is the most points allowed per game in the NFL by a team with winning record; and that number was compiled with the back up QB piloting the offense of 3 of their first 10 opponents this year.

I don’t disagree with you regarding the GM. He has acquired some good players just not enough of them. Then internally, they convinced themselves (and many of their fans) that they were Super Bowl contenders despite having an inability to even win their own Division. 

Now when quality opponents expose the mediocrity and lack of depth on the roster the narrative of their failure is LaFleur suddenly forgot how to be a coach, instead of the truth that there are entire position groups with a lack of impact talent and not enough difference making talent on the whole. 

You certainly saw the picture above where each member of the OL missed their assignment. That’s not coaching, that is lack of execution and effort by the players.

Similar deal with Golden; he absolutely has the talent to be amongst the elite WR in the NFL, but he’s not anywhere close to that tier due to execution. It’s hogwash to say a 2nd year WR is great when he barely played as a rookie and leads the league in drops and has a 58% catch rate in year 2. (Not to mention a collegiate reputation for great hands)

Posted

I don't break down film or anything but I have wondered how much of Kraft's problem is that he is left in to block more often than usual and that their OL doesn't allow time for plays to develop enough to the point that a lumbering TE has a good chance to get open/Love has time to go through progressions.

Posted
1 hour ago, Jopal78 said:

I’d slow your roll with heaping praise on Gannon. Their defense allows 22.1 points per game, which  puts them right in the middle of the pack, and is the most points allowed per game in the NFL by a team with winning record; and that number was compiled with the back up QB piloting the offense of 3 of their first 10 opponents this year.

Similar deal with Golden; he absolutely has the talent to be amongst the elite WR in the NFL, but he’s not anywhere close to that tier due to execution. It’s hogwash to say a 2nd year WR is great when he barely played as a rookie and leads the league in drops and has a 58% catch rate in year 2. (Not to mention a collegiate reputation for great hands)

PPGA is so useless. They "allowed" 27 points to New England, which by itself would rank like 29th in the NFL, then get credited for 7PA against a Bears team that played without Caleb Williams. I would use something that goes a lot deeper, like this. Their defense is probably barely in, or just outside of, the top 10. Whether they are 9th or 19th, still a massive, massive improvement from last year post-Parsons injury. They were atrocious.

"Focus drops" being an issue was literally on Golden's college scouting report. He was basically James Jones. Made acrobatic catches but dropped passes all the time. Golden is fine though, using him as some kind of excuse for MLF is laughable, he's the best WR2 this team has had in years.

Like most things, I think reality lives somewhere in the middle. Fans have (until this year) drastically overstated the talent on the team, and MLF has built a lucrative career off being pretty much average but happening to get playoff spots - due to expansion - that kept him from being canned. Ed Policy is OK with that, it keeps things lucrative. They are not serious about being a real contender though. This regime has shifted from the historical expectation of being in "Titletown" to treating a playoff appearance like the Browns would.

The conversation with Gute can just stop at the OL. That and that alone is grounds to terminate your GM. They are historically terrible and it is a direct result of his mangled drafting and FA.

Posted
50 minutes ago, OldSchoolSnapper said:

PPGA is so useless. They "allowed" 27 points to New England, which by itself would rank like 29th in the NFL, then get credited for 7PA against a Bears team that played without Caleb Williams. I would use something that goes a lot deeper, like this. Their defense is probably barely in, or just outside of, the top 10. Whether they are 9th or 19th, still a massive, massive improvement from last year post-Parsons injury. They were atrocious.

"Focus drops" being an issue was literally on Golden's college scouting report. He was basically James Jones. Made acrobatic catches but dropped passes all the time. Golden is fine though, using him as some kind of excuse for MLF is laughable, he's the best WR2 this team has had in years.

Like most things, I think reality lives somewhere in the middle. Fans have (until this year) drastically overstated the talent on the team, and MLF has built a lucrative career off being pretty much average but happening to get playoff spots - due to expansion - that kept him from being canned. Ed Policy is OK with that, it keeps things lucrative. They are not serious about being a real contender though. This regime has shifted from the historical expectation of being in "Titletown" to treating a playoff appearance like the Browns would.

The conversation with Gute can just stop at the OL. That and that alone is grounds to terminate your GM. They are historically terrible and it is a direct result of his mangled drafting and FA.

The line quality has progressively dwindled ever since Stenavich was promoted beyond OL coach due to other coaches leaving for their own promotions as coordinators/head coaches.  That along with poor drafting/OL aquisitions have turned what was the strength of the Packers' org into its biggest weakness.  If you can't block at the NFL level, you can't expect to win consistently enough to be a title threat no matter how great your skill positions or defense is.

Posted

This is what the NFL is designed to do - rotate the teams at the top.  The inverse order of the draft, the salary cap, the comp picks... it's rare that you have a Brady/Patriots or Mahomes/Chiefs team that can sustain success.  

We'll see how well the Lions do with their All Pro pass rusher and ILB on IR.  Minnesota is pinning their hopes on a 38-year-old QB.  The Bears had to endure four consecutive 10+ loss seasons and six consecutive non-winning seasons to get to where they are.  And none of them have won a Super Bowl in 40 years.

It's all part of life in the NFL.  And if Gutey didn't trade up to get Love, they would be in a lot worse position.

Posted
18 minutes ago, LouisEly said:

This is what the NFL is designed to do - rotate the teams at the top.  The inverse order of the draft, the salary cap, the comp picks... it's rare that you have a Brady/Patriots or Mahomes/Chiefs team that can sustain success.  

We'll see how well the Lions do with their All Pro pass rusher and ILB on IR.  Minnesota is pinning their hopes on a 38-year-old QB.  The Bears had to endure four consecutive 10+ loss seasons and six consecutive non-winning seasons to get to where they are.  And none of them have won a Super Bowl in 40 years.

It's all part of life in the NFL.  And if Gutey didn't trade up to get Love, they would be in a lot worse position.

I question a lot of this. The Packers haven't been at the top in 16 years so I am not sure what rotating is happening as it concerns them. They haven't even made it back to the Super Bowl, which for the purposes of this topic I would say is the same as winning it. 

They have kinda been in the middle for a good bit of time now unless Rodgers is having an MVP year. 

This post reads a lot like an excuse for Gute. I am not seeing the state of the Packers as the result of "parity," as much as poor roster construction. There's a solid argument that NFL parity is quite drastically overrated compared to other leagues. The NBA has made dynasties all but impossible recently. Even baseball, with its silly salary rules, has probably produced about as much parity as the NFL in terms of titles.

I don't think you can say the Patriots and Chiefs are "rare" when they have dominated the last 25 years. Throw in Philadelphia and San Francisco and we have what? I've lost count, but 6 Super Bowl appearances between the two since 2013? Seattle has been there 3 times since 2012. For the most part, the cellar of the NFL goes largely unchanged. Probably 20 or so teams open the year with virtually no chance, due to success being so heavily dependent on a QB that most teams don't have. 

Week to week parity in the NFL is always strong. With league champions, I think you can actually make an argument it's the worst of the major leagues. It's probably the league where you can most quickly go from 4 wins to 10, but the "parity" seems to be more of "Which team with a franchise QB will end up #1 of the top 10 this year."

Posted
20 hours ago, ReverendBrewmeister said:

It's an offensive NFL line versus an NFL defensive line.

Yeah, I saw it happen live and thought, "Oh a screen"...and then they handed the ball off.  🤦‍♂️

"Rock, sometime, when the team is up against it, and the breaks are beating the boys, tell 'em to go out there with all they got and win just one for the Uecker. I don't know where I'll be then, Rock but I'll know about it; and I'll be happy."

Posted
2 hours ago, OldSchoolSnapper said:

I question a lot of this. The Packers haven't been at the top in 16 years so I am not sure what rotating is happening as it concerns them. They haven't even made it back to the Super Bowl, which for the purposes of this topic I would say is the same as winning it. 

They have kinda been in the middle for a good bit of time now unless Rodgers is having an MVP year. 

This post reads a lot like an excuse for Gute. I am not seeing the state of the Packers as the result of "parity," as much as poor roster construction. There's a solid argument that NFL parity is quite drastically overrated compared to other leagues. The NBA has made dynasties all but impossible recently. Even baseball, with its silly salary rules, has probably produced about as much parity as the NFL in terms of titles.

I don't think you can say the Patriots and Chiefs are "rare" when they have dominated the last 25 years. Throw in Philadelphia and San Francisco and we have what? I've lost count, but 6 Super Bowl appearances between the two since 2013? Seattle has been there 3 times since 2012. For the most part, the cellar of the NFL goes largely unchanged. Probably 20 or so teams open the year with virtually no chance, due to success being so heavily dependent on a QB that most teams don't have. 

Week to week parity in the NFL is always strong. With league champions, I think you can actually make an argument it's the worst of the major leagues. It's probably the league where you can most quickly go from 4 wins to 10, but the "parity" seems to be more of "Which team with a franchise QB will end up #1 of the top 10 this year."

Looks to me like the Packers have been pretty good. I think GB fans are simply pretty spoiled.

None of this is meant to be an argument against changing the leadership however. I'm on board with changing the HC and while I'm more forgiving when it comes to Gute I also don't have much issue with folks wanting him to be replaced either. Basically they might be able to to better and odds of doing worse is probably less than Gute backers would think.

image.png.cf66bae3e2d02fd556566187bcfc6c31.png

Posted
26 minutes ago, SeaBass said:

Looks to me like the Packers have been pretty good. I think GB fans are simply pretty spoiled.

None of this is meant to be an argument against changing the leadership however. I'm on board with changing the HC and while I'm more forgiving when it comes to Gute I also don't have much issue with folks wanting him to be replaced either. Basically they might be able to to better and odds of doing worse is probably less than Gute backers would think.

image.png.cf66bae3e2d02fd556566187bcfc6c31.png

The old "spoiled Packer fan" trope. It really shouldn't be that hard for Packers fans to admit that the Rodgers era was overall an organizational failure, but that is such a boring discussion we can let it die there.

Where to begin with this. First off, I'd be careful using what I assume is AI for this because I already spotted mistakes. The Seahawks have played in 4 Super Bowls since 2000 and won 2 of them, which draws into question the entire thing. That is leaps and bounds above GB.

Ranking these teams numerically is pretty much a joke, as I don't know anyone who would claim the Packers are more successful than the Chiefs, Seahawks, Eagles etc. since 2000. Nobody really thinks that unless they place a few 9-8 seasons as equal footing with winning a Super Bowl. Hell, even playing in one.

I didn't say the Packers were bad over the last 25 years. I said parity in the NFL is tremendously overstated. It's kind of become a thing people just say without actually looking into it. 

If you're referring to this: 

"They have kinda been in the middle for a good bit of time now unless Rodgers is having an MVP year."

Then I'd simply say yeah, that's what the Packers have been for about 6 years or so.

The NFL as a whole has a pretty predictable cellar year in and year out. The teams with good QBs will likely be the contenders if that QB doesn't get hurt. My thesis is really that "NFL has so much parity" is more image than reality.

Posted
2 minutes ago, OldSchoolSnapper said:

The old "spoiled Packer fan" trope. It really shouldn't be that hard for Packers fans to admit that the Rodgers era was overall an organizational failure, but that is such a boring discussion we can let it die there.

Where to begin with this. First off, I'd be careful using what I assume is AI for this because I already spotted mistakes. The Seahawks have played in 4 Super Bowls since 2000 and won 2 of them, which draws into question the entire thing. That is leaps and bounds above GB.

Ranking these teams numerically is pretty much a joke, as I don't know anyone who would claim the Packers are more successful than the Chiefs, Seahawks, Eagles etc. since 2000. Nobody really thinks that unless they place a few 9-8 seasons as equal footing with winning a Super Bowl. Hell, even playing in one.

I didn't say the Packers were bad over the last 25 years. I said parity in the NFL is tremendously overstated. It's kind of become a thing people just say without actually looking into it. 

If you're referring to this: 

"They have kinda been in the middle for a good bit of time now unless Rodgers is having an MVP year."

Then I'd simply say yeah, that's what the Packers have been for about 6 years or so.

The NFL as a whole has a pretty predictable cellar year in and year out. The teams with good QBs will likely be the contenders if that QB doesn't get hurt. My thesis is really that "NFL has so much parity" is more image than reality.

I had spotted that error too, I'd like to think the overall records are close.

Success is subjective. They've been to and won one Super Bowl in the 2000s. For some that's not enough, for others it is (while of course still wanting more).

As a franchise they've been winning a lot of football games since the Favre era. I know I've looked up their playoff success since 1993, the first year they made the playoffs under Favre and since then they've been a playoff team in 25 of those seasons through last season. They've never gone more than 2 years without a playoff appearance in that time. I think it would be difficult for many other NFL franchises to be able to claim that same level of success.

I don't know that I have the stomach to only accept Super Bowl appearances as a good enough reason to support me being a satisfied fan. That does feel like spoiled fan feelings. Sorry if that bothers you. Calling it how I see it.

Posted
5 minutes ago, SeaBass said:

I had spotted that error too, I'd like to think the overall records are close.

Success is subjective. They've been to and won one Super Bowl in the 2000s. For some that's not enough, for others it is (while of course still wanting more).

As a franchise they've been winning a lot of football games since the Favre era. I know I've looked up their playoff success since 1993, the first year they made the playoffs under Favre and since then they've been a playoff team in 25 of those seasons through last season. They've never gone more than 2 years without a playoff appearance in that time. I think it would be difficult for many other NFL franchises to be able to claim that same level of success.

I don't know that I have the stomach to only accept Super Bowl appearances as a good enough reason to support me being a satisfied fan. That does feel like spoiled fan feelings. Sorry if that bothers you. Calling it how I see it.

I would say that objectively, if we're looking at 25 years as a whole, the Packers are securely a top 10 NFL team, probably more like Top 8. Are they more successful than some teams that got lucky and won twice, like the Giants? I'd say yes. 

Are they more successful than Kansas City - a team that had the same legendary play at QB that unquestionably did more with it and built better teams? No. Are they more successful than Philly, winning it twice, appearing 4 times, and doing so with three completely different regime changes? Not a chance. Seattle grabbing 2/4 and again, with three different regimes? No.

Super Bowls shouldn't be the sole barometer who is successful. But neither should compiling regular season winning % with very little to show for it.

But again - that's all veering from my real point. Parity in the NFL isn't that much different from the other leagues. More so than the other leagues, one position determines the majority of your success and most teams retain that one guy for a decade.

Posted
1 minute ago, OldSchoolSnapper said:

I would say that objectively, if we're looking at 25 years as a whole, the Packers are securely a top 10 NFL team, probably more like Top 8. Are they more successful than some teams that got lucky and won twice, like the Giants? I'd say yes. 

Are they more successful than Kansas City - a team that had the same legendary play at QB that unquestionably did more with it and built better teams? No. Are they more successful than Philly, winning it twice, appearing 4 times, and doing so with three completely different regime changes? Not a chance. Seattle grabbing 2/4 and again, with three different regimes? No.

Super Bowls shouldn't be the sole barometer who is successful. But neither should compiling regular season winning % with very little to show for it.

Yeah as to your last sentence, I kind of like to see them getting to the championship round, basically the Final Four of NFL. They've done that plenty of times. They have just unfortunately not gotten past it. They probably should have at least twice since 2011 but that's the pain we bear as fans. Is it enough? I'm not sure.

Brewer Fanatic Contributor
Posted

I think there is a bit of over reaction to a game where GB had four turnovers.

"Dustin Pedroia doesn't have the strength or bat speed to hit major-league pitching consistently, and he has no power......He probably has a future as a backup infielder if he can stop rolling over to third base and shortstop." Keith Law, 2006

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

×
×
  • Create New...