Kid just walks right into AFL against top pitchers in baseball and tore them up. The AFL is a notorious hitters' league. And when Gennett starts 'tearing it up' above high-A ball, then I think people will show the love. But as someone who has seen him play in person several times, imo he's simply going to have to put on a lot of muscle to be a legit hitter at the big-league level (or maybe even just the higher levels of the minors). Beyond his physique/frame, his BB/K ratio has been terrible so far in the minors -- that's another indicator that a player's hit tool won't translate well at the higher levels. I count myself as a Gennett fan, but his defense & lack of size right now outweigh the free-swinging singles & doubles hitter when I think about his prospect status. I think he is a legit Top 5 Brewer and Top 80-100 in milb prospect. I don't know how you can say that, his defensive limitations take a huge cut out of his value. If he could handle SS at even an Eckstein-ian level, I'd be all about him. But he can't, and from what I've read about him, he's been about Eckstein-ian at second base, which isn't a good sign. He doesn't hit enough to overcome the defense, & you'd have to hit a ton to be in a top 100 prospect in the entire league with basically a negative on your defensive scouting report -- top 100 is a huge honor imo. But as we all know, rating guys who have proven nothing such Jungmann, Bradley, Lopez deserve all of the praise. Well each of those guys doesn't need to grow in a fashion that looks unlikely for their repsective frames, and have many other reasons for being highly regarded.