Are people completely forgetting the numbers he put up with the Brewers last year before being traded? He was pretty awesome, and while he's not likely to be that good again, I doubt he's as bad as the 4.5 ERA he put up in Baltimore. Somewhere in between is going to be pretty good, especially for a guy that can step right into the closers role if need be. I don't condone abuse obviously, but charges were dropped, so we don't necessarily know everything. Though I'm sure he did something wrong, we don't know and are jumping to conclusions that aren't necessarily fair. And the season before, he put up a 4.38 ERA over a full season. Like TheCrew07 noted, his velocity has long since ceased being an edge for him, & his mechanics aren't strong. You just have no idea what you're going to get from him.