Brian... I would say that DM did have payroll support this year. You can almost make some of the same arguments for firing Melvin as you can for firing Ned, namely that while he was the right person to bring respectability to the organization, he might not be the right person to help push the team "over the top" in his role. I would argue that the last two major trades by DM have not exactly worked out in the Brewers' favor: 1. Linebrink for Inman et al has been beaten to death here, both for what the Brewers gave up and for the pitcher (complete with "worn-out" arm) that was acquired. 2. Estrada/Vargas/Aquino for Davis/Eveland/Krynzel may have looked good on paper when the deal was first made but... I'd be willing to argue that Estrada has hurt the team more than he's helped it. Vargas could have been swapped with Villanueva (maybe having Vargas working out of MR from the get-go and Villy in the rotation would have allowed both of them to flourish, but I digress) and the #5 spot in the rotation would have been better. And Aquino....http://static.yuku.com//domainskins/bypass/img/smileys/sick.gif Melvin needs to be held accountable for acquiring the player that are presently on the team. We can go around and say "DM fleeced such and such 2 or 3 years ago," but as the Astros' shakeup shows, this needs to be very much a "what have you done for me lately" deal around here if the Brewers really want to move above mediocrity. Unfortunately, the answer to the question "What have you done for me lately" for DM is... not much. I don't like Estrada, but I don't see how anybody else we have right now would be a better alternative. How was that trade bad? Davis was asking for a 3 year contract or threatening to go to arbitration. Ther is no way we would want him for the next 3 years. He looked last year very much like Vargas has this year so that is a wash. Aquino didn't turn out, but Krynzel was going nowhere with us so we at least gained onother arm. So the trade boils down to Eveland vs Estrada. Eveland didn't exactly make the most of his chances last year and I doubt wold have been much better this year. As for the Linebrink trade, we will have to wait and see how good Inman really is. Linebrink has been hit and miss so far, but if he turns it up for the rest of the year the trade will look good. Every team that has gotten rid of Melvin has gotten worse after his departure.