I think there are many folks here who have forgotten just how bad Joey was at the dish in 2025. Remember all those times coming to bat with bases loaded? It was sickening.
He felt like an automatic out most of the season, and we have people here acting like all was fine.
I think people can drop all the stats they want, but if you watched as many games as I did, you can't possibly think his 2025 season was passable. It wasn't.
It's fine to compare him to other all glove and no bat SS, but our line-up can't absorb players like him, We don't have the pop to make up for it. Yes, he was our #9 hitter, and what can realistically be expected from a #9 hitter, blah blah blah, but that doesn't mean we have to just accept that he was TERRIBLE last year, and not look for a replacement. Finding that replacement is another story all together (and probably a story for a different thread), but just because he was a horrible #9 hitter doesn't mean we can't expect better in 2026 from someone else.
It's great that we can forgive and forget, but offensively, Joey is not our answer at SS. Most playoff contending teams would be searching for a replacement, that's just how it is.
Can he rebound and be 2024 Joey? Possibly, and if he does, that would be great, but what if he doesn't and we have a re-run of 2025?
We seem to want to act like everything in 2025 was just fine.
Well, it wasn't.