I'm not giving up Black or Quero for Alonso. 1.5 years of a guy who isn't enough to push us over the edge is an overpay, severely.
Hold on to Black, Quero, Chourio, and Frelick and be happy as hell we did 2 years from now.
One player like Goldy or Alonso isn't going to be enough of a difference maker to get us deep into the playoffs. It's going to take at least another top bat for us to have a chance.