It seems some like to argue for the sake of arguing.
Hiura more than likely, with great probability, will outperform all the garbage we've tried at DH this season, yet there are people so hung up on his K% (even though he has improved that stat immensely this year at AAA), his defensive inflexibility, etc., that they can't understand that his only role on the team would and should be as our every day DH.
It's that simple.
Bring the kid back up, tell him he will be the daily DH, and go with it.
I know what CC will do, and so do many others here. He will get brought up, get 2 or 3 starts a week, probably against lefties, which he struggles with, then everyone will jump on his back saying how horrible he is, and "see, he sucks!". It's happened before, and I see it happening again once he gets the call. It's almost like CC and the organization want him to fail for some weird reason. Do I think they want him to fail, no. Yet they continue to put him in situations that do not allow him to reach his potential. I think what we have done to him mentally is a baseball crime. It's asinine.
If we aren't going to use him, I truly hope they find a trade partner who can see some value in him, even if it means we get peanuts in return.