Henderson hasn't been the same since that MVP type season, Last year and this year, his numbers are down, so much so that he is basically just a guy.
Sure, he could bounce back anytime,, but it's been over a year and a half since that 2024 season, and all his numbers have decreased. 17 homers this year, finished last year with 17 homers, but that is a long way from his 37 in 2024. Batting average has cratered, and he is no longer a threat to steal. Anyone can look up his numbers for comparison year by year. He just isn't a difference maker right now, and especially not the kind of difference maker it takes to win the World Series this season.
Holiday has been awful and hurt frequently for 2 seasons, and right now, looks quite a bit like a bust.