What do you think will happen? It just seems obvious that he's the odd man out. As a starter Bush and Capuano are ahead of him the way Melvin talks. In addition we've traded for or signed a plethora of relievers so it doesn't appear he has a place in the pen either. Making things even more difficult is a growing perception (mostly mine I admit) that his trade value is near zilch, even though he's a servicable pitcher (you gotta admit he was an good #5 starter last year ). Plus, there are other complications. It seems to me, and maybe the saber-dudes can help me out, that his talent lies in getting hitters out in scoring position. Sure he lets in his fair share, his ERA proves that, but as a percentage he seems to be not so bad, suggesting that maybe he really would be a bullpen help, kinda like the opposite of Turnbow who has to be brought in at the beginning of an inning, Claudio could be brought in when the fire is hot. And then there's Zach Jackson. I mention him because it seems to me that if Claudio is kept around for injury insurance, to be used temporarily, then a guy like Jackson could just as easily fill that roll, knowing that as soon as injured starter is back AAA would be beckoning. And then there's the trade again, I think it would just drive Melvin crazy to cut Vargas because it's gonna make him look lame here. Trading Doug Davis away is one thing, but virtually giving him away is an entirely different thing. So what's gonna happen? a) he makes the team b) he's DFAed c) he's traded for a middling prospect at best d) he makes the team because someone else is traded and the other pitcher represents better value, ie Bush, Capuano And futhermore, if we cut Vargas or trade him for virtually zero does it mean: a) we've come a long way as an organization with an ability to disgard pitchers who have some value, or b) Claudio's stint proves that we've made a mistake in our long term planning