That's a bit of a stretch. Supposedly the Brewers' offer was like 5 years and $100 million total. I hate talking like that was some sort of low ball offer. That is still huge money for any player. The Yankees went 2 extra years and tacked on an extra $60 million. They were irresponsible, disrespectful to the game, and threw their cash around like only they usually can. There was nothing the Brewers could do about that. But to talk like the offer the Brewers made to Sabathia was some token gesture is kind of disingenuous, in my opinion. It was a token gesture. Yes the Yankees spent more by putting on more years, but everyone knew Sabathia was getting $120-$130m over 5 years. The Brewers came in 20% below the expected market rate. Sure the Brewers would have loved for Sabathia to accept it, but there was no reason to think he would.