Simply pointing out that of the pitchers in there, there's really not a lot of consistency with FIP's to ERA's. I just don't think that there's that much to it. Suppan was nearly flawless last year in the second half, and his three year average was 3.95, so I just don't buy that he was better last year. I just think it's too flawed. IMO, while he had more K's this year, he also gave up a LOT more hits, a higher Whip, his K/BB ratio was better three of the last four years... So yea, I just don't believe that this was Jeff Suppan at his best or even norm. I'm under no illusions that he's a great pitcher, but I do think he's a number 3, and a 4.00-ish type guy. You're missing the entire point about FIP if you compare it to ERAs. Its not meant to show ERA, its meant to show what the pitcher controlled. Pitchers have very little control over BABIP after you account for the type of pitcher. Suppan gave up more hits because his defense sucks compared to last year.