As far as I go back, which is to the 50s, using the phrase jewboy, calling adult black males 'boy', using the term nappy-headed(in the news a while back) were and still are in some circles phrases used to denigrate minorities. That some people in these groups have chosen to adopt some of these phrases within their own trusted circle doesn't mean all members of minorities are comfortable with it or that it's mainstream. Not everyone seeing that avatar was going to see the issues thread and the explanation and a good number of new or casual readers would wonder what kind of ship Brewerfan is running. I know you're trying to run a tighter ship on language, personal attacks, political attacks etc. than Yahoo, mlb, espn and I for one appreciate it. Turning being sensitive about an at best questionably insulting avatar into charges of anti-semitism is ridiculous. To me his later posts made it seem more of an anti-politically correct crusade than anything about Jewish pride. One of the best and also the worst things about the internet is the anonymity. You say you have no reason to not believe him but you also have no reason to believe him either, except our desire to believe most people are on the up and up and give them the benefit of the doubt. I don't know what went on privately with this but if it were my site, I would have deleted it first, asked questions second and wouldn't have reinstated it. I would have explained the reasons above and asked for compliance. If someone isn't willing to comply with that I would just assume they're not interested in being a meaningful contributor to the site. Seems pretty much what you guys did.