While I think objectively I agree, here are the Brewers' compensatory & supplemental 1st rd. picks from the last 4 seasons -- 2009: Kentrail Davis (1s, for Sabathia), Kyle Heckathorn (1s, for Shouse), Max Walla (NYY 2d, for Sabathia) 2010: None 2011: Jed Bradley (for the Dylan Covey non-sign from '10) 2012: Victor Roach (DET 1st, for Fielder), Mitch Haniger (1s, for Fielder) In this case, you might toss out the Bradley pick since it wasn't from letting a player walk. But my larger point is that the Brewers haven't yet done very well 'letting [Player X] walk for comp picks'. That's more about identifying talent for draft day than it is about operational strategy, but I think too often as fans we just assume good value will come from comp picks. So far, the '09 picks have been completely disappointing. Hopefully Roach & Haniger fare better. The main argument for not just letting him walk is that we can get more major league ready prospects by trading him. If we just take draft picks, they likely won't help for 3-4 years, and that doesn't help us compete in the next few years.