Here is more how I see it: Exceeding expectations: Marcum - has been great out of the gates. Slowed a little lately, but still above what I expected. Wolf - I generally argued against the "Suppan II" crowd, but he is still better than what I expected this year. Mitre - My expectations were quite low, so being "solid" exceeds those expectations. Pitching to expectations: Estrada - Has been up and down, but back-end BP/6th starters will do that. Axford - Maybe slightly above expectations, but I thought he could repeat last year. Narveson - I expected a 5th starter. Which is about what he has given (maybe a little above that). As others said, about the same as last year. Gallardo - Started slow, then dominated. Overall, his numbers are about his norms. Not pitching to expectations: Greinke - Below mainly because of the injury and slow start. Has been coming on strong with some dominating starts. Over the last month, I would put him in the "As Expected" category. Loe - Below expectations, but mainly due to usage by the coaching staff, IMO. Being used too often and exposed to big lefties (Votto) too much. Braddock - I don't know where to put him. Pitches well, but unreliable with this sleeping issue and other things. Too soon: Hawkins - He has pitched very well, but just very limited also... Dillard - As others said, fringe MLBer, but not enough innings to know anything. Stetter - been too injured and up and down between MLB and MiLB