I gave him a 3, which is relative to other MLB 1B's. He's bad, but he's not on the level of guys like Dunn and Jason Giambi. His scooping ability and his ability to save others from errors seems to be pretty poor, but there are quite a few 1B's who do both of those things poorly. His range is pretty poor, but could be worse for a guy of his size. So, I'm giving him a 3.