Instead of using hindsight, lets look at the present Brewers: If the Brewers have learned anything by all this, they'll trade Aoki this year or in the off-season...when players are good and have value is when you trade them... NOT when they start to decline (Gallardo, Weeks) or get injured a lot (Hart, Ramirez) and then you don't get as much back for them at all....other than Greinke (and that was more about $$$) the Brewers always wait until a player is on the decline to trade You need to look at the roster and keep a core group (in this case I would say Segura, Gomez, Braun and maybe Lucroy) and then you need to trade the other players who aren't long-term cost controlled to replenish your farm system Even on a decline, Gallardo & Weeks still have trade value, and Ramirez certainly does. Aoki really does. Lohse does to a degree too. Axford is mostly a salary dump. Hart as well if he can get healthy might have value None of them have the value they might have had in the past, but again we're not using hindsight here You trade those guys, restock your talent, hope that Jimmy Nelson develops, hope you can turn Peralta around and hopefully you've brought back more pitching from all those trades.