The prior 8 seasons suggest that the past two seasons were the outlier and that he would improve. He's not a 2.43 ERA pitcher, and he's not a 5.63 ERA pitcher. He's a 3.75 ERA pitcher/4.00 xFIP pitcher. I'm also not convinced that there are better options in the minors. Woodruff - likely. Hader - maybe, but not this season (depends on how much CS is affecting him, as he was dominant in AA) as his innings limit will be around 150 so you can forget about him starting in September. Lopez - unlikely (his peripherals are much better than his ERA, but again the question is how many innings he can go as well as making the jump from AA). I agree with you, LouisEly. Woodruff might be ready to go, but I really really don't want to rush him after a whole 6 weeks at the AAA level. Hader screams reliever to me. Lopez IMHO is the closest to ready but he sucked at AAA last year. Ortiz is still at least 1 year away.