Not sure what world you guys who are saying this would be a bad move are living in, but from the Brewers perpective, with talents like these, its pretty much now or never. Sure they will be both be controlled and cheap for another couple years, but with every day that passes closer to Free Agency, there is obviously less and less incentive for the player to even consider it. You have to go through 1-year contracts, potential arbiration hearings, etc. and there is nothing positive that is going to come out of that. Once they start going through that stuff, you can pretty much say goodbye to keeping these guys beyond teh period you own them. Obviously that is not something teh Brewers want to see happen. There is a pretty brief window of time where you can make it appealing to share the risk with the player. Next year, year after, its probably too late and the players will simply decide to take their chances with arbitration and FA. The Brewers are in a posirtuion to somewhat control the negotiations at this point. As time goes by, they lose more and more of that control, and the price goes up.