Melvin's whole experienced/successful criteria is just silly, imo. Melvin should choose candidates based on their philosophy on baseball, not whether they happened to manage good teams or not. Sure Brenly had success in Arizona, but anyone would have had success in Arizona with that team. Then look at Joe Maddon. He may lack experience and previous success, but his philosophy on baseball is solid. His punting of the closers role has been masterful. I would much rather have some relatively unknown guy with baseball smarts than a well-known, respected idiot who was lucky enough to manage a great team.