Francisco, 10 HR, 26 RBI, .943 OPS, 1.4 WAR Overbay, .592 OPS, -0.5 WAR The "gritty veteran" Overbay has been worth 2 wins less than Francisco so far, as far as WAR goes. If they had made the right decision in the first place and just kept the better player instead of overthinking it for the sake of defense, we wouldn't be talking about this problem so much.