Fielder, McGehee, Betancourt 2011 combined: 1876 PA, .259/.327/.433/.759 with really bad defense Justin Upton 2011: 640 PA, .243/.331/.429/.759 with good (I think) defense So upgrading 3B and SS can offset what we'll lose at 1B. SS is the same offense but now plus defense. If we can upgrade 3B and get someone that can throw from first to home, the team might not miss the loss of Fielder.