Between April and mid-September, he was fattening up on a whole lotta Oriole, Blue Jay and Devil Ray pitching. I don't think that really had much to do with anything. He can (and did) hit just about everybody. However, when even the best players fail over half the time, it's pretty easy to put together rough strings against anybody. For example, from July 23 until August 1, the Yankees played Kansas City, Baltimore, and the Chicago White Sox, three terrible teams. A-Rod went 3-31 in those games, even against crap teams. A-Rod also went 10-27 with 5 homers in a stretch in April against Cleveland and Boston, two teams with very good pitching. My point with these examples is that one can cherry pick whatever stretches they want in a season to find good stretches against good pitching and bad stretches against bad pitching. While your theory would seem to make sense, I can find stretches like the above two mentioned to show that it's not really the case. I guess what I'm trying to say is that it doesn't make much sense to say that one of the best players of all time doesn't deserve a big contract based on 30-some random at-bats.