I don't think the influence of his agent and the Players Union has been really taken into consideration. Both have an interest in him taking the highest offer, both have persuasive powers wayyyy above Brewerfan pleading with him to come back, so I don't get the surprise and incredulity here. We offered (for us) a king's ransom and it was still short by the equivalent of the GDP of Bulgaria. It's nonsense to suggest that Melvin overplayed his hand - he presented a deal, CC took his good time while all the bargaining went on and, finally, the inevitable happened. The Hot Stove hasn't exactly been piping hot for pretty much every team without the word "Dodgers" in their name. And if Melvin decides CC was gone at the outset, and goes out to get a FA pitcher, what message does that give? We gave it a shot, but I'd rather have that than just sigh and give up without a try. There seem to be a number of prom analogies flying around, but I think this is more like the movie Some Kind Of Wonderful. The Brewers are Eric Stolz, all blue collar and lacking in self esteem. CC is Lea Thompson who only dates the rich kid (the Yankees) because her friends (the Players Union) tell her to, even though there's something about the cut of Stolz's jib that she likes. For the benefits of the analogy Mr. Cut-of-his-jib is Mike Cameron. Ultimately, she's out of his league (natch), but he eventually winds up with Mary Stuart Masterson who's secretly been admiring him for some time, and they are a much better match together. So, Doug, go out and find the Mary Stuart Masterson who wants to pitch for the Brewers and we're set!