I think this is basically where I am, too. If Gomez doesn't improve, then clearly it's a bad move by Doug. But I think of it this way: Scenario 1: Hardy bounces back, Gomez never improves Scenario 2: Hardy stays bad or average, Gomez never improves Scenario 3: Hardy bounces back, Gomez improves as Doug bets he will Scenario 4: Hardy stays bad or average, Gomez improves as Doug bets he will Yeah it's an oversimplification, but only one of those scenarios ends poorly for the Brewers. If Hardy doesn't bounce back, then I can't imagine doing better than this, and I don't see the point in debating who else he could have gotten, because there's no way we can know all of the options. At the same time, I'm not sure you can really include Cameron in this deal, because it's likely that Gerut + platoon partner would do no worse (or better) than Gomez next year, so you could've traded Hardy, let Cameron go, and still have all that cash to spread around (plus whatever player you got back in the alternate universe Hardy trade). I also think that this means there's no way Kendall can be back next year, and the comments from Doug so far indicate he's leaning that directly too. It'll be interesting to see how this plays out. I just hope Looper is gone..