Jump to content
Brewer Fanatic
Verified Member
Posted
18 hours ago, Ro Mueller said:

Was thinking Bauers will grab a multi-year contract somewhere else, while we go with Vaughn and a minor league free agent like Dominic Smith to start the season.

Then Burke comes up after the Super 2 deadline passes.

Why not just go with Tyler Black as the left side 1B until Burke or Fischer are ready to come up. It doesn’t have to be a straight platoon. Still give Vaughn plenty of starts vs RH starters and see how it goes. Save a few million on bringing a retread in who’s only going to be Rengifo’d mid season.  If Black doesn’t perform well, at least now we know there is zero future there.  Go ahead and DFA him opening up a 40 man spot. 

  • Like 2
Posted
4 hours ago, PBTank said:

Why not just go with Tyler Black as the left side 1B until Burke or Fischer are ready to come up. It doesn’t have to be a straight platoon. Still give Vaughn plenty of starts vs RH starters and see how it goes. Save a few million on bringing a retread in who’s only going to be Rengifo’d mid season.  If Black doesn’t perform well, at least now we know there is zero future there.  Go ahead and DFA him opening up a 40 man spot. 

Is this real? 

Posted
58 minutes ago, KCBrewerfan34 said:

Is this real? 

I hope not.  If the Brewers were rebuilding, I would be fine with that approach, but we have a legit shot at repeating as World Series champions.  We can’t replace our best offensive player with frankly a player that hasn’t shown anything to make anybody think he’ll ever be a major league player.

Someone else said it earlier, but I think we need to stack our team right from the start so we don’t have to overpay for what are very limited scraps at the trade deadline.

I think we need to stay with Bauers as plan A on the QO, and then roll with Vaughn with one of the rookies as part of the soft platoon at first as Plan B.

if black can show something in spring training and AAA to beat out Fischer, he can have his shot.   Otherwise, he is probably best served by getting into a bottom 10 organization who might have playing time available and nothing to lose

Community Moderator
Posted
2 hours ago, KCBrewerfan34 said:

Is this real? 

Instead of just a snappy, snarky response - you could articulate why you think it's a bad idea.

  • Like 1
Verified Member
Posted
41 minutes ago, Team Canada said:

Instead of just a snappy, snarky response - you could articulate why you think it's a bad idea.

The Tyler Black idea was only a temporary roster spot until Fischer or Burke shows they can handle AAA.  Plus depending on the new CBA rules, they might want to manipulate their service time until June or so.  In that Scenario, Vaughn is the starting 1B.  Black would only be once in a while spot start and LH bench bat for a few months.  

Brewer Fanatic Contributor
Posted
8 hours ago, PBTank said:

Why not just go with Tyler Black as the left side 1B until Burke or Fischer are ready to come up. It doesn’t have to be a straight platoon. Still give Vaughn plenty of starts vs RH starters and see how it goes. Save a few million on bringing a retread in who’s only going to be Rengifo’d mid season.  If Black doesn’t perform well, at least now we know there is zero future there.  Go ahead and DFA him opening up a 40 man spot. 

Smith has signed minor league deals the past 3 offseasons and I assume he’s due for another one.

I think he’s a better defender and offers a bit more pop than Black.

Either way, Smith/Black would be expected to serve as a 2-month filler just until Burke is activated.

Posted

I'll throw out some random buy low arm names.

Darwinzon Hernández - Returning from NPB after a really strong season

Andrés Machado- Same.  Looked good in the WBC

Michael Kopech- Sounds like he's making a comeback after knee troubles last year.

Posted
3 hours ago, wallus said:

Drew Rasmussen and Joey Ortiz have about the same BTV trade value. Food for thought.

That website is beyond a joke, it’s click bait. Rasmussen has one year of control remaining at a hefty price and Ortiz has 3 arbitration eligible seasons remaining so their algorithm says they’re equal. The reality is no GM swaps a #1 starter for Joey Ortiz. Or no GM swaps Rasmussen for a 3B/SS with middling power. 

Posted
11 hours ago, Jopal78 said:

That website is beyond a joke, it’s click bait. Rasmussen has one year of control remaining at a hefty price and Ortiz has 3 arbitration eligible seasons remaining so their algorithm says they’re equal. The reality is no GM swaps a #1 starter for Joey Ortiz. Or no GM swaps Rasmussen for a 3B/SS with middling power. 

The Brewers do similar stuff all the time . A cy Young winner for 6 years of Joey and 6 years of DL Hall.  You just hope the prospects turn out.

Posted
2 hours ago, Mr Southpaw said:

The Brewers do similar stuff all the time . A cy Young winner for 6 years of Joey and 6 years of DL Hall.  You just hope the prospects turn out.

But they actually didn’t; it was Burnes for Ortiz AND Hall as rookies/pre-arb players.
 

The  original poster said that according to that dumb website Rasmussen and Ortiz were equal value in its algorithm. No GM is swapping Rasmussen for Ortiz straight up in November of ‘26

Posted
30 minutes ago, TwinsBrewersWorldSeries said:

I’m not sure why people are so excited to trade TM?  He has been our best reliever for 3 years.

lets lock in for 2027, make him a QO, and cash in another pick :)

Can't see the team giving a 34 year old Megill the QO

  • Like 1
Posted

Didn't want to make a new thread but is there any chance the Brewers start to get involved with the Asian posted players? I feel like we do great on trades and drafting but have not really done much here.

Yes I am aware that Milwaukee might not be the top market for those players but we did just win the World Series. If there is any time to try, it might be now.

Posted
1 hour ago, wallus said:

Didn't want to make a new thread but is there any chance the Brewers start to get involved with the Asian posted players? I feel like we do great on trades and drafting but have not really done much here.

Yes I am aware that Milwaukee might not be the top market for those players but we did just win the World Series. If there is any time to try, it might be now.

I was thinking about this recently too. What interested me more than traditional free agency is that the players available are generally younger than your typical free agent. However, not too many guys to be had on 1-2 year deals. So ultimately I’m not sure we are any change here from prior off seasons. I’d be surprised to see the brewers involved on any of the NPB/KBO guys. 

Posted
On 11/13/2026 at 3:55 PM, KCBrewerfan34 said:

What about MeGill for Luis Garcia? Both are on expiring contracts. We could trade/non-tender Vaughn. 

No, Luis Garcia doesn't walk, run, and is an iffy defender. He would be one of those play for yourself players Murph was talking about (i know different Yank team Garcia wasnt on).

 

Posted
On 11/14/2026 at 4:21 PM, wallus said:

Didn't want to make a new thread but is there any chance the Brewers start to get involved with the Asian posted players? I feel like we do great on trades and drafting but have not really done much here.

Yes I am aware that Milwaukee might not be the top market for those players but we did just win the World Series. If there is any time to try, it might be now.

I would love to take the risk if the market doesnt take off on Kaino Taira. 5'8" with a mid to upper 90's heater seems like there all sorts different looks for hitters. I would guess it is a lower arm slot and less extension. It would be really interesting to put him after the Mis. Going 6'7" with elite extension to 5'8" would be a huge change. If he was around what Imai got last year last year I would be at least thinking about it. At 27, he is also younger than other free agents and there could be a stuff increase coming states bound. There might be some workload questions but we could easily do a 6 man and save him a little on that end.

Posted
3 hours ago, jay87shot said:

I would love to take the risk if the market doesnt take off on Kaino Taira. 5'8" with a mid to upper 90's heater seems like there all sorts different looks for hitters. I would guess it is a lower arm slot and less extension. It would be really interesting to put him after the Mis. Going 6'7" with elite extension to 5'8" would be a huge change. If he was around what Imai got last year last year I would be at least thinking about it. At 27, he is also younger than other free agents and there could be a stuff increase coming states bound. There might be some workload questions but we could easily do a 6 man and save him a little on that end.

He would be intriguing but It might be difficult. Borass is his agent.

Posted
40 minutes ago, wntrtxn21 said:

He would be intriguing but It might be difficult. Borass is his agent.

I dont think the Boras end plays into it much. Any agent at this point is going to go for the most money, especially with a foreign guy who doesn't have motivation to take a hometown discount. I think it just comes down to the market. If a couple bigger market teams peg him as a number 2 he could get close to $100. If everyone is scared off by his size and lack of starting track record he could get passed over and be like 3 years at 12-18 million, which we could be in on.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Brewer Fanatic Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Brewers community on the internet. Included with caretaking is ad-free browsing of Brewer Fanatic.

×
×
  • Create New...