The former is decidedly NOT exclusive from the latter, however. If you are going to instill a sense of confidence in your team and players, you actually have to follow though with what you say, sometimes by sticking with guys longer than they deserve (Loe and McGehee). It's not like the Crew clearly had other better options at the time. Once they did (K-Rod and Hairston), Roenicke played they guys he should have. As far as the rest of his in-game decision making, I'll take the fact that the Brewers significantly outplayed their pythagorean record as proof that Roenicke knows what he his doing more often than not. Perhaps he just got lucky, but we won't really know until a few more seasons go by. Kotsay in CF for the playoffs, however, is totally ridiculous and indefensible. I can't figure that one out. As others have said, I think Green would have been a much better option than McGehee. I also think Ron lacked the ability to think ahead. Getting Green some MLB ABs in June would have shown us if he was a viable option later in the year. Same with getting Lucroy some rest occasionally to keep him fresh, or overusing some bullpen arms.