Almost every starter on the offense that Hornibrook led went on to play in the NFL. They had talent (and health).
When Chryst had a zest for the job - and before there was NIL and the transfer portal - he did a great job of recruiting. Then all three of those things changed - there was NIL, there was the transfer portal, and Chryst lost his zest for the job.
We've been down this road many, many times, but in college football teams are led by upperclassmen. Upperclassmen are the result of the recruiting efforts of 4-5 years ago.
And a fourth thing changed - the B1G. According to ESPN's Football Power Index, the Badgers had the toughest schedule in the nation this past season including conference championship games:
https://www.espn.com/college-football/fpi/_/view/resume/sort/resume.avgsosrank/dir/asc
So much has changed, you really can't compare college football today to pre-2020. The transfer portal decimates depth almost everywhere - kids aren't going to sit for 3-4 years now. The development model that UW thrived on is dead; you can count the number of scholarship players left from 2022 on the 2025 team with your fingers and toes, and you don't need all of your hands and feet. Kids are going to leave and go where they think they can play. You can't develop players who are no longer there.
We live in an era now where, because of the portal and NIL, there can and will be tremendous fluctuations from year to year in teams, and injuries to key starters, particularly QBs, will completely derail seasons. Success is dependent on deep pockets and injuries now more than ever. A healthy Sam Leavitt and ASU goes to the CFP last year and beats Texas Tech this year; an injured Sam Leavitt, and ASU gets blown out by Utah and Arizona and barely beats a 4-8 WVU at home.
Texas Tech is a middling team in a middling conference in 2024 with a defensive efficiency rating of 83rd in the nation; a billionaire spends a bunch of cash, and they now have a CFP first round bye and are #1 in the nation in defensive efficiency. High school recruiting doesn't vault a team from 83rd to 1st in one year. No change in head coach either.
It's a different era now, and you can't compare it to pre-2020.