Russell Smith and Justin Yeager get no love around here.
Russell Smith gets the benefit of being a lefty, and has only given up 1 HR in 37 IP this year; walks are a little high, but down from last year and tall lefties take a while to harness control (and despite those walks only has a 1.168 WHIP). Yeager is the forgotten part of the Contreras trade after missing almost all of 2023, but has taken the closer role at Biloxi to the tune of 14 saves and, IIRC, has a pretty big arm (and a 1.066 WHIP). Maybe the minor league mavens @Joseph Zarr@Spencer Michaelis@wiguy94 can update me on Yeager's scouting report.
I'm also excited about Crow, but with his FB sitting in the low-90's before TJ and with Rule 5 picks having to stick in the majors, I don't know that a team is going to pick him and make him do essentially his "rehab assignment" at the major leagues. His first go-around in AA wasn't great, even if it was aggressive placement, but he only has four good games in AA in 2023 to demonstrate he can handle the jump to AA, much less the majors. I just don't see another team taking the risk on carrying him the whole season.
If I'm ranking them, it's:
Henderson
Patrick
Shane Smith
Yeager
Russell Smith
Crow
Collins
My 2-5 are all very, very close to each other. The odd thing about the Rule 5 is that relievers are more likely to stick with the drafting team than starters, so a big part of me wants to put Yeager at #2.