I built a detached garage around 30 years ago. It was in West Allis. We removed the old one, had the concrete taken out and repoured.
I used to work for a construction / carpentry company for a few years and had a good relationship with the owner. I had asked if he could help out (and bring his tools). He was OK with that. When he showed up, he asked where I got the materials. I said from Menards as a kit.
"Menards? Are you kidding me?"
Mind you, we built houses in more of the upscale communities on the north side and up to Sheboygan, so our typical lumber came from Cedarburg Lumber or Neu's.
With that said, though, I drive by the garage today (we moved out 25 years ago), and it looks just like it did when we built it. I had help roughing it in and then my wife and I put up the shingles, facia, soffit, gutters, one window, and siding.
After that long story, I guess I'm saying not to be afraid to look at what Menards has to offer. The lumber was a little more crowned than the Cedarburg / Neu's stuff, but it is still standing today 🙂