To be honest, I did a little searching and didn't see anything like this. After last night's meltdown, it got me thinking about how much better Hader + Williams was. Williams has been lights out this year and he certainly would not have many saves if Hader was still around. It also doesn't address how tired the bullpen was -- that might have been solved with having one less starting arm and one more bullpen arm... but I digress.
For fun, I thought I would see how the Hader trade has panned out so far. Recall, it was:
Padres receive Josh Hader
Brewers receive Robert Gasser (minors), Dinelson Lamet, Taylor Rogers and Esteury Ruiz.
Hader: 0-1; 18 Saves in 31 appearances. ERA of 1.21. 29.2 IP, 45K .944 WHIP
Gasser: AAA Nashville; 5-1 4.00 ERA; 74.1 IP; 1.251 WHIP; 87K; 2.9 K/BB
Lamet: Put on Waivers and picked up by the Rockies 4 days after the trade
Rogers: Currently with San Francisco; signed as a free agent on 12/28/22; had a 5.48 ERA in 24 appearances with Milwaukee
Ruiz: Currently with Oakland; 3 games with the Brewers in 2022; was part of the trade where the Brewers received William Contreras and Joel Payamps.
Not sure how Gasser will do. Happy with Contreras and Payamps. Would we say it was a push as far as who won this trade... so far?