As much as the people at B'Ville don't want to admit it, it is an offshoot of the old "Badgermaniac" site. One of the prominent members of that site got frustrated with certain things and started the B'Ville site. I joined the Badgermaniac site wayyyyyy back around the time when Barry Alvarez was thinking about going to Miami.
I agree with Jim 100% that it is very, very toxic. If you post something that might have been said before, you are thrown under the bus. If you try to defend a position, you are met with 10 counterpoints. However, as Jim said, it is a good place to find out insider information. Although, it was amusing how defensive the "insiders" on the site became when Fickell was named head coach. Jeff Potrykus posts on the site and even he was thrown under the bus because even his sources were bamboozled. Just like many other online communities, people live their lives on the board and are very passionate about things.
That is one thing that I appreciate bout the BrewerFanatic community -- people bring up counter points, but it isn't in the style of, "You stupid m***** f*****!" To the mods -- keep up the great work!