Gwynn Jr.'s skillset (contact hitter, speed) fit the role of a leadoff hitter. The problem is his skills aren't....well...good enough to be an everyday hitter, regardless of position. I'm willing to accept a leadoff guy who just gets on base for the heart of the lineup, but without a .360+ OBP, he needs to have a SLG that's at least comparable to OBP. (Even going that far, I'm pretty sure I'm in the minority.) TGJ is good enough defensively to be a 5th OF / pinch runner, but isn't going to be a starter unless he turns into a .300 hitter, starts taking walks more often, or develops some extra-base pop. At this point, it's hard to expect any one of those things to happen. Going back to Weeks, I'd like to see the Brewers hold on to him for at least one more year, but bring in someone to split time (non-platoon) with him. From an outsider's perspective, Rickie always seems to have his most productive times after the team lights a fire under his backside (demotion to AAA, Durham trade, etc.). I don't know whether it's because he benefits from splitting time, or because he needs the motivation, but it has worked in the past.