If you sort by WAR from ‘94-now it goes Rodriguez, Bonds, Pujols, Trout and Chipper as the top 5 for hitters. For a list like this I think you need to separate the hitters and pitchers.
If you use WAR Braun doesn’t come into the picture until 70th just behind Jose Reyes. People have to remember Braun was absolutely horrible at 3B defensively. Braun’s career D-WAR was only 1.5 better than Nelson Cruz.