I'd guess I'd like to see some era-adjusted context for Gantner's numbers as others did for the Scott/Sexson numbers. Gantner's career BA was significantly higher than Weeks' career BA. Overall Fangraphs has it pretty close... Gantner: 6787 PA | 87 wRC+ | 19.5 WAR Weeks: 4700 PA | 108 wRC+ | 18.6 WAR Weeks clearly more dynamic offensively, Gantner with longevity & an ability to actually field the position. Weeks fares much worse by DRS (-113) than UZR (-46), though, so their BRef WAR isnt particularly close with Gumby at 22.5 & Rickie at 12.5. Adjusting their batting lines for era looks a little something like... Player: AVG+/OBP+/SLG+ | K%+/BB%+ Weeks: 94/104/102 | 131/122 Gantner: 104/97/89 | 55/66 Both are pretty illustrative of their era with Gumby never really walking or striking out & dinking a bunch of singles, while Rickie traded average & contact for power & walks. For my all time Brewers team I'd probably cheat a little & slot in Molly at second. In the four seasons he was a primary 2B he managed over 15 bWAR with positive fielding numbers, so not really as much of a stretch as it might seem.