I agree that trading Hader had short-term negative effects. I think that's undeniable. I don't think those were inevitable. I think Rogers was bad in a small sample, and he was the piece intended to mitigate those impacts. If he performs wonderfully, I don't know that we're talking about this. He didn't, but was that really predictable? Team took a shot and missed.
But the long-term value they got was there and is paying dividends.
I don't fault them one bit for that trade. Sometimes, the results aren't what you want exactly, but these results are pretty good, and the process felt exactly right to me. The Brewers have to run by thinking in 2, 3, and 5 year increments. They've been very good at that over the last decade or so. In that sense, I don't know how anyone can villify this trade. You can mourn 2022 and the small but significant role the trade may have played in that, but I'll take these kinds of results every time.