Then compare ages. That's the point. Nix at 25----.347/.506, 853 OPS, 176 OXS Nelson, 25--.409/.488, 897, 199 Brad is better, but considering Nix plays a pretty good CF, they are comparable. What people are saying is that he'd likely be a 800ish OPS guy and that's pretty much average for a first baseman, which in other words means he would be no worse than about half of the rest of baseball. The AL averaged 791 last year, but the NL 846, so 820 is much more accurate. Considering he's an 800 career OPS guy in AAA, imagining he'd be a 800 OPS guy in the majors seems rather optimistic, to say the least. As I have said before, ignoring his previous 750ish AB's in AAA and going with only his '08 numbers seems to be cherry picking, even if he did have an injury which may have sapped his power. I don't see it. He's too old to be much of a prospect, and he's not good enough to be compared to Jack Cust and the like.