As many point out, when you argue batting order, you're arguing semantics. There is no right or wrong batting order. Next, Counsell has not started versus a LHP. Saying no platoon exists is incorrect, and does nothing. As I will say for the final time, Counsell is a better defender than Branyan, and quite apparently, they are choosing to go with him because of his approach at the plate. Choosing to say he is 0-9 and using the tiniest sample available, and then saying Ned should not go with the hot hand...at best, is spinning in circles. I don't notice many line drive outs of late, so his leash is likely getting tight. However, as often occurs, I do find it ironic that many insist on saying the team should improve the defense, and then complaining every time they play the better defensive player. You'll also see many folks saying Cameron is dragging the team down, yet not only has he been good defensively, he's outperformed Hart in the batter's box. This is far from the case with Craig, but you can also make the same case with Kendall, as they love the way he works his staff. Russell has also had many balls go off his glove or just past him at 3B. I tend to feel it's a good idea to go with the best offensive lineup, as some guys won't see a single play all night. However, some will, though no one knows who. Counsell is a wonderful defender, who may have saved the game the other night, or at least a couple runs that may have changed the complexion of the game. Escobar will almost certainly replace Hardy at SS soon, and is very unlikely to match his offense, at least for a few years. Defense does have value, it is just difficult to measure.