Casey performed better against major league pitching than Gamel did against AAA guys. The debate is nonexistent. Mat needs to prove himself again, and when he does, he'll have a spot. Gamel should be able to put up a .400/.500 AAA line before even thinking about returning. The Brewers do not have "open battles" in spring training for starting spots, nor should they. It's a tiny sample, and Doug and the braintrust know it. Even for the bench spots, only Casey did anything after having a decent 50 PA's against inferior competition...Nelson and Duffy both reverted back to form and were soon in AAA. It's also a bit misleading he did not play much in his 2 months up. He had 131 PA's, about a 400 PA pace, which is not a small amount at all...as pointed out, Casey barely played his first couple months, and still contributed when he got the chance. Excuses are for guys who are banged up and at half-speed, not for a guy "only" playing 4 days a week. Hit more, play more. As good a season as Craig and Casey had, they earned their playing time.