The thing is, Escobar would probably only hit .310/.330, or something along those lines...with very good defense of course, that's arguably an average SS. Doing so at $350K is a wonderful value, and allows funds to be spent elsewhere. What many don't seem to realize is JJ with 2 years left before free agency is worth more than JJ with a year left before free agency. If they get good value for him, Alcides will be the SS in '09. Another thing that often goes unmentioned is the Brewers have to "fix" 3B before putting Escobar at SS. Having a bottom of the order of Counsell, Escobar, and Kendall, while not terrible OBP wise, would be devastating SLG wise.