I don't like to start threads, but I want to get some things off my chest and a thread with this title seems like a good place to rant.
I am an optimistic fan. I have predicted 90+ wins the last few seasons. I go to a good number of games, attend spring training, and am old enough to have been a Brewer fan since 1970. I dumped $3942 into NLDS and NLCS playoff tickets (Games 6 and 7 will be refunded, of course) because if there was going to be a World Series in Milwaukee, I was going to be there.
These playoffs broke me.
Same old, same old. I was at both Arizona games in 2023, all three Mets games last year, and both home Dodger games this year. I cannot imagine enjoying next season as much because I will feel as if the lack of slugging in the playoffs will doom the Brewers once again. I was in a meeting in Chicago on the day of NLCS Game 4. When the meeting ended, it was 3-0 in the first. I abandoned my plan of driving to a bar to watch. I just drove home to Madison.
Bites of the apple, run-prevention, and the AAA bullpen shuttle that I have come to respect and enjoy won't matter if the Brewers cannot score in the post-season. This model works in the regular season, but fails in October. If they run this back without significant offensive help, I will watch with detachment next year. No more woodpeckers, get me a raptor (not Brent Suter).
I can't even get as worked up about the Brewers' Annual Devastating Injury on the Eve of the Playoffs, 2025 edition. Losing Brandon Woodruff was not the reason the Brewers couldn't get past the Dodgers. Having LA score 2, 3, 5 and 5 runs should not be insurmountable, but it was this year. Milwaukee has scored 32 runs in their last 16 playoff games, dating back to 2019. They went to game 7 of the LCS in 2018 with Ryan Braun, Mike Moustakas, and Travis Shaw playing significant innings despite defense that was less than stellar. But they scored 38 runs in 10 playoff games that year. I'd be willing to take that tradeoff.
Maybe none of this matters. There is no single bat that can bridge the gap between LA and MKE. There probably aren't even two bats. But, damnit, I'll take a puncher's chance at this point.
EDIT: I messed up, as was pointed out in a later post. The 32 runs in 16 games disregards the Cubs series. I just forgot, and was thinking only of series where they lost. The Brewers scored 22 runs in those five games alone. So, it's 54 runs in 21 games. Better, but still around 2.6 per game. I still believe that the Brewers don't slug enough to win playoff series.