For you I will concede that you do watch. For the vast majority of people waffling over Hicklen not being selected to the 40-man, they are strictly basing it off his numbers, so providing context for those numbers is important. Also Perkins is one of if not the best defensive outfielder in baseball. Hicklen does not provide defensive value near that level, so for him to provide value in the MLB it would need to be with the bat so his quality of contact is important. When his quality of contact isn't amazing in AAA, it's very easy to question how it would translate to the MLB.