a couple thoughts: it was known that kevin gullikson was the person in question when his situation occurred. there was no question about who did what. same with the shoebox ordeal. the greeks are scrutinized for hazing. they are overseen by the UW, and in particular, the same dean of students office that acted on the band. i believe the sig ep house was investigated for some hazing that took place just this past spring. fraternities have been suspended and removed from the UW for their actions. i served on the greek council in madison (about 10 years ago now) and we received complaints of hazing that were investigated and dealt with by higher ups in the university...especially when they involve physical harm or dangerous binge drinking. the problem with fraternity hazing is that nearly nobody complains about it. i was hazed, but the hazing didnt involve anything that i thought to be overly negative or threatening/dangerous. my fraternity had a hazing problem a couple years before i arrived and the situation was handled by the university. the older guys educated the younger guys about what was OK and what was not, and we passed that information to guys younger than us. my wife's sorority was placed on probation (all of them) by both the university and their national council for a drinking incident that only a couple people were involved in. it sounds like there was a complaint that was serious enough to require discipline and there was not enough time to determine who the culpable parties are/were. third hand stories made it sound like there was an initial effort to stonewall the investigation, which may have led to the severity of the punishment.