I don't have a problem with him asking for a high price in return for the ball, but just as with the Jenkins HR ball, he gets out of line when he asks for item(s) from players not involved in the situation. Ask for all the tickets or merchandise from the team you want, make Coghlan give you a bat, helmet, jersey, whatever, but asking for stuff from another player is probably both quite insulting to the player whose milestone you obtained, and also pretty embarrassing to him as well. Also, again, this thread is on VERY shaky ground- I don't see the value in criticizing anyone for their hobby, but I think it's fair to criticize the method in which they do it if there's questions about that. But at no point is it ok to call someone a 'jerk', 'lame', etc otherwise this thread is going to be closed.