You don’t see the factor, though, of the time amount remaining in the game and the idea that this could easily be a last possession wins game?
If Campbell does that with 10 minutes left, I agree that it’s not a good decision.
When there’s 4 minutes left and he punts, the Packers need to go maybe 30 yards to get in FG range and there’s an excellent chance the Lions never get the ball back.
And even if Smack misses, it’s then just OT, not Lions necessarily win because they don’t get last possession.