I know this might look really weird, but what if we just sorted by OBP? Note: I switched Braun and Fielder to aid in R-L separation, despite Fielder out OBPing Braun by .001. vs. RHP 1) Braun 2) Fielder 3) Weeks 4) Hart 5) Jenkins 6) Hardy 7) Hall/Gross 8) Estrada 9) Pitcher vs. LHP 1) Braun 2) Fielder 3) Weeks 4) Hart 5) Hardy 6) Hall 7) Mench 8) Estrada 9) Pitcher That LHP lineup would have a serious out-making problem at the bottom of the order. Both Mench and Estrada are only getting on at a .298 clip, .012 better than Yo. I don't really mind the RHP lineup, though. Conventional wisdom would say that it would waste Braun and Fielder at the top of the order, but they are our best hitters, so they should get up more often than our not so good hitters. Also, the big boppers will only be up with no chance of baserunners once per game. After that, they've got just about the same chance as anyone else of batting with ducks on the pond